Checklist for Reporting Foreign REIT Income

Tax

Investing in foreign REITs offers portfolio diversification but comes with complex U.S. tax rules. To avoid penalties and maximize returns, you need to follow specific reporting requirements. Here’s what you need to know:

  • Key IRS Forms: File Form 8621 for PFICs, Form 8938 for foreign assets, and Form 1116 to claim foreign tax credits.

  • PFIC Rules: Many foreign REITs qualify as Passive Foreign Investment Companies (PFICs), requiring annual status checks and detailed filings.

  • Tax Benefits: Eligible deductions and tax treaties can reduce withholding taxes (e.g., from 30% to 15%), but only with proper compliance.

  • Currency Conversion: Convert foreign income to USD using the correct exchange rates for accurate reporting.

  • Penalties: Non-compliance can result in fines starting at $10,000 for missing forms like Form 8938.

Accurate record-keeping is crucial. Save proof of transactions, tax payments, and currency exchange rates. Professional tools or tax advisors can simplify compliance and ensure you meet all obligations while optimizing your tax strategy. Follow this step-by-step guide to stay compliant and make the most of your foreign REIT investments.

Where Do REITs Go on a Tax Return? - CountyOffice.org

Foreign REITs and U.S. Tax Rules

The IRS applies specific rules to foreign REITs, which can significantly influence both tax obligations and filing requirements. Unlike domestic investments, foreign real estate investment trusts (REITs) are subject to unique classifications and tax treatments that investors need to understand.

What is a Foreign REIT?

A foreign REIT is a real estate investment trust established outside the United States. While these trusts operate similarly to U.S. REITs - pooling investor funds to manage income-generating properties - their tax treatment under U.S. law differs. Foreign REITs do not qualify for the pass-through dividend benefits that domestic REITs enjoy. Additionally, foreign corporations that cannot attain REIT status in the U.S. are excluded from these tax advantages.

Due to these differences, many foreign REITs fall under the Passive Foreign Investment Company (PFIC) classification, which comes with its own set of tax rules and reporting requirements.

PFIC Classification Rules

Foreign REITs often generate rental income and capital gains, making them likely candidates for PFIC classification. A PFIC is defined as a foreign corporation that either earns the majority of its income passively or holds assets that produce such income. The IRS uses two tests to determine PFIC status:

  • Income Test: At least 75% of the corporation's income is passive (e.g., dividends, interest, rents, royalties, or capital gains).

  • Asset Test: At least 50% of the corporation's assets generate passive income.

Since foreign REITs typically earn rental income and capital gains from their holdings, they often meet one or both tests.

PFIC classification has significant tax implications. It generally results in higher tax rates and more complex reporting, including the requirement to file IRS Form 8621. Completing this form is no small task - the IRS estimates it can take around 49 hours. Investors must also choose a tax method for handling PFIC investments. Here are the main options:

To check if an investment might be a PFIC, look up its International Securities Identification Number (ISIN). An ISIN starting with "US" indicates it is not a PFIC, while other country codes often suggest PFIC status.

The PFIC rules aim to prevent U.S. taxpayers from deferring or avoiding taxes on passive income earned via foreign entities. Once a foreign REIT is classified as a PFIC, gains are taxed as ordinary income, which usually results in a higher tax burden compared to the more favorable capital gains rates. Before investing in a foreign REIT, it's wise to investigate its PFIC status and understand the associated tax obligations.

Given the complexity of PFIC compliance, many tax professionals advise against holding offshore PFICs. Instead, they often recommend investing in U.S.-registered funds, which can simplify tax reporting and potentially lower overall tax liabilities. Properly identifying PFIC status is crucial for navigating the reporting process, which will be detailed further in this guide.

Required IRS Forms and Documents

Reporting income from foreign REITs comes with specific IRS requirements, especially if the REIT qualifies as a Passive Foreign Investment Company (PFIC). This adds layers of complexity to the process, as additional forms are needed beyond the standard dividend reporting. Here's a breakdown of the key forms and what they entail.

Form 8621: PFIC Income Reporting

Form 8621 is central to reporting PFIC income. You must file this form if you:

  • Receive distributions from a PFIC.

  • Sell or dispose of PFIC shares.

  • Make a Qualified Electing Fund (QEF) or mark-to-market election.

  • Hold PFIC investments valued over $25,000 (single filers) or $50,000 (joint filers).

Each PFIC investment requires its own Form 8621. This document captures details about income types, elections, and any adjustments for excess distributions or mark-to-market calculations. Attach Form 8621 to your annual tax return and ensure it's filed by the deadline, including any extensions.

Starting January 1, 2024, the e-filing threshold for information returns will drop to 10, which may influence how you submit your forms.

Additional Required Forms

Depending on your investment and situation, other forms may also be necessary:

  • Form 1099-DIV: Reports dividends and distributions from foreign REITs. Even if the foreign entity doesn’t issue a U.S. Form 1099-DIV, you’re still responsible for reporting this income on your tax return.

  • Form 8938: Required if your foreign financial assets exceed certain thresholds. This form complements FBAR requirements.

  • Form 1042-S: Used for U.S. source income subject to withholding.

  • Form 1116: Helps you claim foreign tax credits for taxes paid to foreign governments, avoiding double taxation.

  • Form 3520: Applies if your foreign REIT operates as a foreign trust or if you receive specific foreign gifts linked to your investment.

  • Form 5471: Necessary for ownership interests in certain foreign corporations, depending on the REIT’s structure and your ownership percentage.

Record Keeping Requirements

Keeping detailed records is essential for accurate reporting and staying compliant with IRS rules. Here’s what you need to maintain:

  • Transaction Records: Save purchase confirmations, sale receipts, dividend statements, and correspondence. Keep these for three years from your return’s due date or the date it’s filed, whichever is later.

  • Basis Records: Retain these indefinitely to verify the costs of original or replacement property, especially for currency conversion and PFIC elections.

  • Foreign Tax Documents: Hold onto foreign withholding tax certificates and payment receipts to support claims for foreign tax credits.

  • Currency Conversion Details: Keep records of exchange rates used and their sources for all transactions, as foreign currency amounts must be converted to U.S. dollars for reporting.

Note: Starting with 2025 tax returns, failing to file within 60 days can result in a penalty of either the tax due or $510, whichever is less.

Calculating and Reporting Income Types

Investing in foreign REITs (Real Estate Investment Trusts) involves dealing with various income types, each requiring specific calculations and accurate reporting. Keeping detailed records and understanding the tax treatment of each income type can help you avoid costly mistakes when filing your tax return.

Dividend and Passive Income Calculations

When reporting foreign REIT income for tax purposes, it's essential to calculate dividend and passive income correctly. Dividends are one of the most common income types from REIT investments and must be reported on Form 1040. If your combined dividend and interest income exceeds $1,500, you’ll also need to include Schedule B with your return.

Determine whether the dividends are ordinary or qualified. While qualified dividends often benefit from lower long-term capital gains tax rates, foreign REIT dividends typically don’t qualify for these rates. For dividends to be considered qualified, the issuing corporation must either be incorporated in a U.S. possession, operate in a country with a comprehensive income tax treaty with the U.S., or be traded on a U.S. stock exchange. However, in most cases, REIT dividends fall under ordinary income tax rates.

Make sure to gather all distribution statements and convert foreign currency amounts into U.S. dollars for accurate reporting. Currency conversion is a critical step, and the amounts must reflect the appropriate exchange rates. Once you’ve handled dividends, you’ll also need to address capital gains and rental income for a complete tax report.

Capital Gains and Rental Income Reporting

If you sell shares in a foreign REIT, calculating your gain or loss is straightforward: subtract your adjusted basis (original purchase price plus any reinvested dividends) from the sale proceeds. The holding period of the shares matters too. Shares held for one year or less result in short-term capital gains, which are taxed at ordinary income rates. Shares held for more than a year qualify for long-term capital gains rates, which are generally lower.

Additionally, many foreign REITs distribute rental income derived from their property holdings. Depending on the REIT’s structure and any tax treaties between the U.S. and the foreign country, this rental income might be subject to varying withholding tax rates or special provisions.

If your foreign REIT is classified as a Passive Foreign Investment Company (PFIC), you may face additional reporting requirements. Without a timely election, such as the Qualified Electing Fund (QEF) election, you could encounter less favorable tax treatment. To ensure accuracy, keep detailed records of purchase and sale dates, as well as any corporate adjustments, to support your tax calculations.

Lastly, all foreign currency amounts must be converted into U.S. dollars using the appropriate exchange rates, as outlined in the next section.

Currency Conversion Requirements

For tax reporting, all foreign currency amounts must be converted to U.S. dollars using the exchange rate from the date of the transaction. For example, when reporting dividends, use the spot rate from the payment date - not the declaration or record date.

Although the IRS doesn’t mandate a specific exchange rate source, it does require consistency. Acceptable sources include major banks, U.S. Embassies, or reputable online platforms like Oanda.com or xe.com. In cases where multiple exchange rates are available in a country, ensure you use the rate that applies to your specific transaction.

Here’s a quick reference for applying exchange rates:

Document your exchange rate sources and calculations for each transaction carefully. If you receive annual totals in foreign currency, break them down by individual transaction dates to ensure the correct spot rate is applied. Avoid using a single year-end rate unless explicitly allowed, as this could lead to inaccuracies in your reporting.


Transform Your Real Estate Strategy

Access expert financial analysis, custom models, and tailored insights to drive your commercial real estate success. Simplify decision-making with our flexible, scalable solutions.


Foreign Tax Credits and Withholding Taxes

Once you've calculated your income, it's time to address how to avoid being taxed twice on foreign REIT income. This section breaks down the role of foreign tax credits and how to handle withholding taxes effectively. Since foreign REIT income can be taxed both abroad and in the U.S., understanding these processes is critical for accurate filings.

Foreign Withholding Tax Rules

Many foreign countries impose withholding taxes on REIT distributions paid to U.S. investors. Without a tax treaty, the standard withholding rate is often 30% for dividends and rental income. However, tax treaties between the U.S. and other nations can significantly lower these rates. For instance:

  • Canada: REIT dividends are subject to a 15% withholding tax, or just 5% if you hold substantial shares.

  • Germany and Australia: Typically impose a 15% withholding tax on regular dividends, reduced to 5% for substantial holdings.

Your broker or the foreign REIT should provide documentation of any taxes withheld, which is usually included on Form 1099-DIV or similar statements. The timing of when these taxes are considered "paid" matters for U.S. tax purposes. Generally, foreign withholding taxes are treated as paid on the date you receive the income. This timing is crucial for currency conversion and determining the correct tax year for claiming credits. You'll use Form 1116 to claim credits for these withheld amounts.

Form 1116 for Foreign Tax Credit

Form 1116 is your go-to tool for claiming foreign tax credits. It allows U.S. citizens and resident aliens to reduce their U.S. tax liability by the amount of income taxes paid to foreign countries or U.S. territories. This credit provides a dollar-for-dollar reduction in your taxes owed.

When completing Form 1116, you’ll need to:

  • Convert foreign currency amounts: Use the exchange rate from the tax payment or withholding date. If you use accrual accounting, the average exchange rate for the tax year may be applied.

  • Categorize foreign income: Separate income by country and type. For foreign REITs, income usually falls under the passive income category, which includes dividends, rental income, and capital gains.

  • Calculate the credit limit: Ensure you don’t claim more credits than the U.S. taxes attributable to that foreign income.

Accuracy is key. Mistakes on Form 1116 can lead to IRS audits or inquiries. Double-check all currency conversions, confirm income categories, and ensure foreign tax amounts match the documentation from your broker or the REIT. If post-filing changes occur, update your return with Form 1040-X. Notifying the IRS of adjustments is essential, as failing to do so - even if it reduces your credit - can result in penalties.

Keep detailed records of all foreign taxes paid and any carryover amounts from prior years. If your foreign tax credits exceed the current year's limit, you can carry them back one year or forward for up to ten years. Proper documentation will help you preserve these credits for future use.

Below is a helpful summary of treaty benefits by country:

PFIC Compliance and Special Rules

Investing in foreign REITs often comes with a maze of compliance requirements that go beyond simply reporting income. Navigating these rules is crucial to avoid penalties and to optimize your tax outcomes. A major part of this process is determining whether your foreign REIT qualifies as a Passive Foreign Investment Company (PFIC) and ensuring you meet the related filing obligations.

Annual PFIC Status Review

Under U.S. tax law, most foreign REITs are considered PFICs. To stay compliant, you need to check this status every year using the 75% income and 50% asset tests.

One quick way to start is by reviewing the ISIN code. If the ISIN begins with "US", it indicates a U.S.-registered fund, which is not subject to PFIC classification. However, for other foreign REITs, you'll need to dig deeper into the fund's details. If the majority of its income or assets are passive - such as rental income or real estate holdings - it’s likely a PFIC. This means you’ll need to file PFIC reports annually, even if you don’t sell shares or receive distributions.

Keep in mind that a foreign REIT's PFIC status can change from year to year, depending on its income sources and asset composition. If a REIT loses its PFIC classification, your reporting and tax obligations will shift accordingly. On the flip side, if an investment that wasn’t a PFIC becomes one, you’ll need to start filing PFIC reports immediately.

Once you confirm PFIC status, the next step is to handle the required filings.

PFIC Filing Requirements

If your foreign REIT qualifies as a PFIC, you must file Form 8621 every year for each PFIC you own - whether directly or indirectly - even if you didn’t receive any income or sell shares during the tax year. This form is detailed and requires precise reporting.

You’ll need to file a separate Form 8621 for each PFIC with your annual tax return. It’s critical to maintain accurate records, especially if you’ve made multiple purchases over time. The form will ask for specifics like acquisition dates, cost basis, fair market values, and distributions.

Form 8621 also lets you make important tax elections that can significantly impact your tax liability. For instance, the Qualified Electing Fund (QEF) election lets you pay tax annually on your share of the PFIC’s income, even if it’s not distributed. Alternatively, the Mark-to-Market election allows you to treat your PFIC shares as if they were sold at the end of the year, recognizing gains as ordinary income and permitting ordinary loss deductions up to previously recognized gains.

Failing to file Form 8621 or missing the deadline for these elections can lead to higher tax bills and interest charges on deferred taxes, so timely compliance is essential.

Beyond PFIC filings, you may also need to navigate additional rules, such as those under FIRPTA, if U.S. real estate is involved.

FIRPTA and Other Special Rules

The Foreign Investment in Real Property Tax Act (FIRPTA) adds another layer of complexity for foreign REITs that hold U.S. real estate. FIRPTA ensures that U.S. taxes are collected on the sale of U.S. property interests. In some cases, a foreign REIT may be classified as a United States Real Property Holding Corporation (USRPHC), meaning its shares could be treated as U.S. Real Property Interests (USRPI). If this applies, gains from selling those shares may be subject to FIRPTA taxes, which override the usual capital gains treatment.

It’s also important to review your holdings if you invest through partnerships or other pass-through entities. Special rules apply when ownership in publicly traded partnerships exceeds 5%. While most individual investors don’t hit this threshold, it’s worth monitoring, especially if your investments are structured through entities that might make elections on behalf of all partners.

Corporate investors face different considerations, such as when income is recognized and what tax elections are available. Additionally, estate and gift tax implications may arise for foreign REIT holdings, particularly for high-net-worth individuals with significant international investments.

Tools and Professional Resources

Dealing with the complexities of foreign REIT reporting and PFIC compliance can feel overwhelming. Thankfully, specialized tools and expert resources are available to simplify the process. These resources not only streamline tasks like annual PFIC status reviews and Form 8621 filings but also ensure accuracy, minimizing the risk of costly errors and maximizing tax efficiency.

The Fractional Analyst Services

To tackle the intricate reporting requirements of foreign REITs, The Fractional Analyst offers tailored financial analysis and expert insights specifically designed for commercial real estate investors. Through their CoreCast platform and elite analyst support, investors gain access to solutions that make navigating international investment reporting much more manageable.

Their custom financial analysis services are particularly valuable for evaluating foreign REIT investments before purchase. By providing detailed underwriting and asset management support, these services help investors anticipate PFIC implications and tax outcomes upfront - avoiding surprises later. Tailored financial models include features like foreign tax withholding calculations and currency conversions, integrating these complexities directly into your investment analysis.

For ongoing compliance, The Fractional Analyst's investor and lender reporting services simplify the documentation needed for Form 8621 filings. The platform tracks essential details like acquisition dates, cost bases, and fair market values, ensuring accurate and timely PFIC reporting while reducing the risk of penalties.

The CoreCast platform, available during its beta phase for $50 per user per month, adds another layer of convenience. This real estate intelligence tool automates compliance tracking and documentation, flagging potential issues with foreign investments before they escalate into expensive problems.

Additionally, The Fractional Analyst offers free downloadable financial models, such as multifamily acquisition models and IRR matrices. These tools can be customized for foreign REIT analysis, helping investors assess international opportunities while factoring in currency conversions and PFIC status right from the start.

Benefits of Professional Help

Platforms like The Fractional Analyst bring a level of expertise that general tax software simply can’t match. With PFIC rules being highly specific and subject to frequent changes, having access to dedicated professionals ensures compliance and reduces the likelihood of errors.

Avoiding mistakes is one of the biggest advantages of professional assistance. Missing a single Form 8621 filing or improperly timing an election can lead to hefty tax bills and interest charges. Professional services systematically track all foreign investments, ensuring no PFIC is overlooked and that all required elections are made within IRS deadlines.

Another benefit is real-time monitoring and risk assessment. For instance, if a foreign REIT’s PFIC status changes from one year to the next, professional platforms can identify these shifts and adjust reporting requirements accordingly. This proactive approach spares investors from unexpected complications and financial setbacks.

The comprehensive compliance support offered by these services goes beyond basic form preparation. Experts can guide investors in structuring their foreign REIT holdings for maximum tax efficiency, whether that means opting for U.S.-based funds to sidestep PFIC challenges or carefully timing QEF and Mark-to-Market elections to minimize taxes.

Professional platforms also provide secure, centralized data storage, which protects sensitive financial information while making it easier to compile reports for IRS audits or other regulatory reviews. This level of organization is invaluable when dealing with complex international investment structures.

Lastly, professional services offer strategic tax planning for your entire portfolio. Instead of addressing each foreign REIT in isolation, they optimize election timing across multiple PFICs and coordinate foreign tax credit strategies to enhance after-tax returns. Often, the savings and benefits gained from this holistic approach outweigh the cost of the services themselves, ensuring compliance while improving overall tax outcomes. These tools and resources integrate seamlessly with the strategies discussed earlier, offering investors peace of mind and better results.

Conclusion

Reporting foreign REIT income accurately requires careful attention to compliance details. Start by determining PFIC status, ensuring timely filing of Form 8621 for each PFIC investment, and handling currency conversions properly. Don’t forget to claim foreign tax credits using Form 1116, attach Schedule B, file Form 8938, and submit FinCEN Form 114 if thresholds are met. Following this checklist can help you stay on top of your obligations and maintain accurate records.

Given the complexity of these rules, thorough record-keeping is essential. Document every dividend payment, capital gain, rental income distribution, and instance of foreign tax withholding with precise dates, amounts (both in foreign and U.S. dollars), and supporting evidence. Keeping comprehensive records of all transactions and filings is crucial to avoid costly penalties.

Using specialized platforms can make a big difference. These tools can automate categorization, reconciliation, and tax preparation, offering a more efficient and accurate alternative to manual processes. Starting with a solid reporting process allows investors to spend less time worrying about compliance and more time focusing on the growth of their foreign REIT investments. For added support, consider professional resources like The Fractional Analyst (https://thefractionalanalyst.com) to simplify compliance and enhance your investment strategy. These steps can help streamline your reporting and improve your tax outcomes.

FAQs

  • Foreign REITs that fall under the classification of Passive Foreign Investment Companies (PFICs) come with notable tax consequences for U.S. investors. Distributions from PFICs are often taxed as "excess distributions", which are subject to the highest federal income tax rate. This can significantly raise the overall tax burden. On top of that, profits from selling PFIC shares are generally treated as ordinary income, adding to potential tax liabilities.

    To meet IRS requirements, investors must file Form 8621 each year. This form is used to report holdings, income, and any elections made, such as the Qualified Electing Fund (QEF) or mark-to-market options. These elections can alter how income and gains are taxed but require precise reporting and careful decision-making. Missing these obligations can lead to penalties, so it’s crucial to stay informed and consult a tax professional if necessary.

  • U.S. investors can cut down on taxes from foreign REIT dividends by leveraging tax treaties that might reduce the usual foreign withholding tax rate. On top of that, the Foreign Tax Credit (FTC) helps offset U.S. tax obligations by accounting for foreign taxes already paid, preventing double taxation on the same income.

    For even better tax outcomes, look into REITs that meet the criteria for pass-through taxation and check out the possible perks of Section 199A deductions. Keeping up with tax regulations and seeking advice from a tax professional can help you stay compliant while maximizing your savings.

  • To report income from foreign REITs on your U.S. tax return, you’ll need to convert all amounts from foreign currency into U.S. dollars. This should be done using the exchange rate applicable on the date you receive, pay, or accrue the income or expenses. The IRS generally advises using the spot rate for these conversions.

    If you're filing an annual report, you can opt to use the IRS's yearly average exchange rates for consistency. Make sure to keep detailed records of the rates you use and adhere to IRS guidelines. Maintaining accurate documentation not only ensures compliance but also helps minimize mistakes and simplifies the reporting process.

Next
Next

How to Value Ground Leases Using Capitalization Rates